Our Commitment to You
As an independent insurance agency, we represent a diverse array of insurance carriers, ensuring that we can always offer our clients the best value. We invite you to allow us the opportunity to review your current insurance program. Our goal is to provide recommendations that not only enhance your coverage but also help you achieve cost savings.
Welcome to The Stahlka Agency
Since our founding by Donald and Gertrude Stahlka in 1957, Stahlka Agency has been a proud provider of comprehensive insurance services to the Western New York community. Our journey began as a small family business, and under the dedicated leadership of William, Mark, and Brad Stahlka, we have grown into a well-respected firm with over 45 employees. As a third-generation agency, we pride ourselves on our deep roots in the community and our enduring commitment to excellence.
We're also proud to have retained our Best Practices status for three consecutive years, a distinction held by only 235 agencies nationwide.
Insurance doesn't have to be complicated. With us, it isn't.
Insurance can be overwhelmingly confusing. All of the jargon, terms, and coverages can make you feel like you don't understand any of it. Our team educates our clients so they fully understand what their premium dollars are being spent on.
Insurance is never just about price, but we're really good at saving people money.
There are many factors that go into insurance rates, and it's no secret that rates increase every so often. Our mission among other things is to help individuals and business-owners put money back in their pockets.
Why choose us? We believe in old-fashioned customer
service along with a few other core beliefs -
Efficiency
Your time is valuable, so we work quick to deliver results.
Clarity
Insurance can be confusing, we'll make it easy to understand.
Honesty
When other agencies sell you what you don't need, we don't.
B
Bob M
Great Agency! Professional, knowledgeable, friendly and very helpful. If you are searching for any insurance needs I highly recommend. I use them for home, auto and business! Keep up the good work Stahlka Team!
R
Restaurant K
The best most personable insurance company around. If you ever have questions or issues you just call or email your rep and they will take care of things for you. Very knowledgeable and caring. It was the best choice switching my insurance to The Stahlka Agency!
D
David B
Great rates, great coverage, and amazing service. Mark Stahlka is diligent on finding you a great rate while ensuring you have coverage for whatever comes at you. I will never go anywhere else for any insurance needs.
Our friendly & knowledgable team is our greatest competitive advantage.
What makes one insurance agency different from all the rest? Simple - people, personality, and professionalism. At Stahlka Agency, we go above and beyond to ensure your experience with us is one you won't forget.
Are you an existing agency client in need of policy support?
Depending on what type of request you have, it may be fulfilled by our in-house team of CSRs (customer support representatives) or by your insurance carrier directly. If you have an emergency claim, we'd recommend contacting your carrier directly.
Billing
Carrier Contact Information
File a Claim
How to file a claim
Insurance Simplified
At Stahlka Agency we have access to a wide range of both insurance carriers and products. This gives us, and more importantly, you, flexibility and choice when it comes to your coverages and company.
Start A Conversation With Us
Enter some basic information to get started, and our helpful team will take it from there!