About Us

The Stahlka Agency has been proudly serving the Western New York community with insurance services since being founded by Donald and Gertrude Stahlka in 1957. Although our firm started off small, through the years William, Mark, and Brad Stahlka have grown the company to over 45 employees and have established a strong reputation for the Stahlka Agency.

We are an independent insurance agency representing several insurance carriers to continuously find our clients the best value. We would like the opportunity to review your current insurance program and to offer recommendations to improve your coverage and reduce costs.

In 1995, the Stahlka Agency joined other reputable Insurance firms, to form the EMS Group, an independent, community-based group of insurance companies in Western New York. The EMS Group has distinguished itself as a youthful dynamic group, having established a strong reputation as a leader in the insurance business.

Our agency is pleased to operate out of both the Southtowns and Northtowns.  With one office at 6724 Main Street in Williamsville, and our second location at 4250 Southwestern Blvd, Suite 1.